At the ESMO Congress in Madrid a few weeks ago, someone asked me how cancer care was going in Malaysia. I said almost without thinking that what worries me most these days is our healthcare workforce. That brief exchange kept playing in my head on the flight home, and it also brought back a conversation with a friend who had moved from government service to private practice after fifteen years. When we met, she began explaining why she had left, fumbling a little, almost as if she felt she had to justify herself. No one had asked her.
Fifteen years in a public hospital is a long time. It covers thousands of patients, a great many ordinary days on which the work was done well and nobody remarked on it, and the steady business of helping younger colleagues find their way. It was only when my friend left that her career became something to be explained. Doctors who move to private practice are often spoken of as though they were chasing money or had lost their commitment to public service, with little thought for the years they have already given. Whatever their reasons, surely that decision does not erase what they have contributed?
Interestingly, we respond rather differently when a Malaysian doctor or healthcare professional achieves international recognition. There is a familiar sense of national pride. News of their accomplishments travels quickly, accompanied by congratulations and admiration. When that success comes from someone who has built a career abroad, the conversation often turns to why Malaysia could not provide the opportunities that enabled them to flourish elsewhere. We lament the loss of talent, question whether we have invested sufficiently in our people, and wonder what it would take to bring them home. These are legitimate concerns, and I share the pride in seeing Malaysians succeed, wherever they are based.
And what about those who have chosen to stay? Many of them could have left for private practice or for posts abroad, and they stayed. They carried the public health system through the pandemic and through years of shortages, and they are still there today. These are the healthcare professionals on whom millions of Malaysians depend, yet they seldom enter the public conversation at all. I have yet to hear anyone at a wedding dinner ask a government nurse why she has stayed so long, let alone thank her for it.
The way we measure the workforce crisis reinforces this. The Health Ministry has reported that 3,511 medical officers resigned from the Ministry of Health between 2023 and 2025, and such departures are rightly counted and debated. We hear far less about how many have given twenty years or more to the service, and almost nothing about what has kept them there. Much of what long-serving professionals contribute also falls outside anything we routinely measure. In cancer care, I see it every week: the nurse who has taken patients through repeated cycles of chemotherapy and still remembers their children’s names, and the medical social worker who spends an afternoon on the telephone so that a patient can continue treatment. The value of this work is not captured in medical records or the figures we use to describe the workforce, yet our services would struggle very quickly without it.
Perhaps we take them for granted precisely because they have always been there. When someone delivers consistently for many years, we come to expect it and seldom ask what it takes for them to continue. Many of these colleagues helped build the services we now depend upon, often with limited resources. Their commitment is real, but it cannot be sustained indefinitely on goodwill alone, and we should be careful not to romanticise sacrifice when we have come to expect it from the same people, year after year.
There is also something about the middle of a professional career that deserves more attention. After fifteen or twenty years, children are growing up, parents are ageing and the demands of home begin to compete seriously with the demands of work. This is also when professionals are at their most experienced, often carrying substantial responsibility for running services. It is often at this very stage, when the system depends on them most, that it offers them the least room to manage the rest of their lives. My friend’s former colleagues in the public service are at this stage now. That they are still in the service tells us very little about how close some of them may be to leaving, and a national conversation that tends to notice people only once they have gone will not warn us in time.
Saying thank you matters, but I suspect most healthcare professionals would value something more tangible. A nurse who has spent years mentoring younger colleagues should see that contribution recognised in her career progression. A doctor caring for ageing parents should not have to choose between remaining in public service and being there for her family. Meeting these expectations requires institutions to understand that the people who care for us have lives and responsibilities of their own.
I also wonder how often we ask those who remain what would make their working lives better, and more importantly, what happens after they tell us. Staff surveys are familiar exercises in many institutions, but when the findings disappear into reports without any visible response, it is hardly surprising that people eventually stop expecting anything to change. Not every problem can be solved immediately, and some will require resources that are not readily available. However, listening, explaining what can or cannot be done, and following through on commitments would be a reasonable place to start.
I still think about my friend who felt she had to explain why she left. Perhaps the more important question was never why she decided to leave, but whether anyone had asked, while she was still there, what would have made her want to stay.